A cookie cutter with a very mysterious shape has left thousands scratching ... and a 'moon and shooting star.' The OP eventually followed up in the comments: 'Wow, I didn't expect so many suggestions!

A fierce debate has sparked online in a bid to decipher what a mysterious cookie cutter shape was intended to be ... it could be a very abstract Patrick Star from Spongebob Squarepants.

Without packaging or instructions, the shape of a cookie cutter picked up at a secondhand store or rescued from the recesses of a silverware drawer can be hard to interpret. Is it meant to be a ...

And if you happen to have see Ree's newest Cut-Out Sugar Cookie recipe, you might be wondering just where to find the cute cowboy and star cookie cutters ... the simpler the shape, the easier ...

Here are 5 unidentifiable cookie cutters and people's hilarious guesses, along with what they turned out to be: 1.This lumpy, angular shape with all sorts of little extensions: u/Klutzylady_death said ...

can sweetened condensed milk 3 cups white baking ... Using a 2½-inch star-shaped cookie cutter, cut fudge into star-shaped pieces, and transfer to a platter. Store, covered, in refrigerator ...