CINCINNATI — No one needs to tell you about Billy Hatcher. You’ve known him all your life. Billy Hatcher is the young Billy Martin, except dressed in red and white. He’s Gene Tenace.

In the early 1980s, collectors simply couldn't get enough of Cal Ripken (or brother Billy, as it turned out!), and his 1985 Donruss Diamond Kings card was just one more card to take straight to ...