The plate it sat on read “Happy Birthday Hugh Jackman!” in chocolate sauce. Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE's free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has ...

“Hello Hugh. I was just going to wish you a happy birthday,” the Deadpool star said. “Then I saw what you said. In a word, ‘hurtful.’ Enjoy the show, Hugh Jackman.” Reynolds then ...

Jackman then, picking up his baton, encouraged the audience to sing "Happy Birthday" to Sutton Foster ... Foster wrote in her instagram caption, "Hugh Jackman is an evil, horrible, WONDERFUL ...