By 2020s standards, Reneau got the rare chance to learn a bit in his freshman season. Playing behind Race Thompson, Reneau played 14.9 minutes per game and averaged 6.1 points.

Galloway started his Indiana career as an 18.2% 3-point shooter in 2021, but he rose to a very good 46.2% by 2023. However, Galloway plummeted to 26% in 2024. In his final season, Galloway made 32.7%.