Liquid eyeliner is like the white t-shirt of the beauty world—it’s a staple in your closet that goes with every look, but it’s still so freakin’ hard to find one that checks off all the boxes.

Today, a collaboration emerges that not even the darkest of souls could have imagined: Liquid Death and Elf Beauty ... Wispy Cloud), Dead Line (H2O Proof Eyeliner Pen), the Brush with Death ...