Players rave about it when they come every year, but for the course architecture heads and the peripheral golf community, the glass is very much half empty on this week’s PGA Championship venue. So why is the divide so stark?

Few golf course projects had more national attention in recent years than Quail Hollow, mainly because its front nine was redesigned just a year before it hosted the 2017 PGA Championship. Quail Hollow favors long hitters more than any other course on the PGA Tour.

Scottie Scheffler roared to victory in the 107th PGA Championship, losing a five-shot lead and then winning by the same margin. Here’s a look at the final results from Quail Hollow Club in Charlotte,